• 0 Posts
  • 33 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 1st, 2023

help-circle





  • I trained shotokan for a bit having come from a gridiron/rugby background, and there were some exercises (like ring-out shoving exercises) where I was a laughable mismatch with anybody else in the room. One of the trainers was a woman that I had 35cm and 50kg on, if she tried to square up, it would have been hopeless.

    But strength isn’t all of it. There was another three-step positional sparring exercise, and that one trainer tied me into knots every time. I wouldn’t have been able to touch her in a real fight, and she would have popped my kidney like a balloon every time.

    I’m mostly pissed off about stuff like amateur rugby and field hockey not letting trans women compete. In sports like that, at the pro level, the top team would be all men no question.

    But for a bunch of random people in their 20s playing amateur rugby? Piff, the safety/dominance issue is really overblown.


  • eestileib@sh.itjust.workstomemes@lemmy.worldUse your big girl words
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    9
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    The high end of height, upper body strength and mass, sprinting speed, etc definitely favors higher-test systems. .

    But I remember reading an ethnography of a Chinese village in the early days of the PRC, when they were still basically living the Imperial-peasant lifestyle.

    Women there at the time of writing were not generally esteemed as beautiful slender luxury possessions, but instead for virtues such as their ability to carry heavy loads on a yoke, and the male/female strength split was not nearly that big.

    We don’t need to live in a society where we assume that “generic man” is assumed to have an essential advantage in physical combat over “generic woman”. That’s a choice.


  • Men being slightly stronger on average than women has a LOT to do with culture.

    When I was a kid, girls weren’t even allowed to do the same calisthenics in school. There was severe social opprobrium for women doing strength training, learning martial arts, etc.

    This is one of the things about the patriarchy, the things it enforces are seen as natural. Women are put in clothes that limit their mobility, beauty standards demand frailness, etc.






  • I looked around a little bit, and mostly the articles seemed to talk about stooping rather than collapsing backwards into the spine.

    I think it’s cause he’s wearing lifts and has to use his upper body as a counterweight for his belly.

    But he definitely is not there mentally any more, 2016 he was still able to speak in sentences.